Significant Home Sales from May 2025
With the spring market season rapidly approaching its peak, we’d like to share the sales highlights from the month of May! Our agents closed a number of transactions, representing sellers and buyers alike with the luxury service Mahler Sotheby’s International Realty provides.
In Paris, Wisconsin, just outside of Bristol, the homestead of renowned Architect Alfred Caldwell changed hands. Offering a different lifestyle, a home on Lake Drive was sold in Whitefish Bay. The final luxury sales highlight of May is a lake home in Lake Geneva that comes with access to Lake Geneva Beach Association amenities. Read and see more below!
20318 60th St. | Paris, WI
Indulge in the 39-acre homestead of renowned Prairie School Landscape Architect Alfred Caldwell. This distinctive property pays homage to his legacy and features a stone residence, and a studio converted to a guest house—both showcasing Caldwell’s masterful fusion of Prairie School design and modernism. Beautiful terrazzo flooring and floor-to-ceiling windows welcome you into the 1,566-square-foot main house with a bedroom and three baths. A screened porch and stone patios invite you to enjoy this idyllic setting, viewing Caldwell’s picturesque landscapes and mature woods filled with maples, oaks, black walnuts, and hickory trees. A short walk past the gardens and pond with waterfall is the charming guest house, beaming with natural light and priceless views.
2 Beds | 4 Baths | 2,331 Sq. Ft.
Sold for $1,075,000
Listed by Curt Downes
5028 N. Lake Dr. | Whitefish Bay, WI
This home has been masterfully renovated to blend modern sophistication with timeless charm. Inside is a stunning kitchen featuring a large center island, generous dining room perfect for hosting dinner parties and a spacious living room, complete with a cozy fireplace. The first floor includes a convenient office and dedicated mud/laundry room, designed for today’s busy lifestyles. Upstairs, the home features four generously sized bedrooms and three bathrooms, including a luxurious primary ensuite with two walk-in closets and a second guest ensuite. The large backyard creates an inviting oasis and the attached, heated 2.5-car garage adds practicality. Best of all, this gem is situated just one block from Lake Michigan and Big Bay Park.
4 Beds | 3.5 Baths | 3,404 Sq. Ft.
Sold for $1,125,000
Listed by Daria Aitken-Siegel
N1744 W. Beach Dr. | Lake Geneva, WI
This spacious 5-bedroom, 4-bath home offers 4,520 sq. ft. of living space with first and second-floor primary suites. The home features 9-foot ceilings, hardwood floors, a sound system throughout, plus an oversized screened-in porch. This home is perfect for entertaining, offering 13 rooms with multiple spaces for gathering. The open floor plan connects the kitchen to the family room with fireplace, living room, and separate dining room. A partially finished, full basement with 9-foot ceilings, above grade windows, a fireplace, and full bath. The massive garage has over 1,000 sq. ft. and includes 9.5-foot ceilings, two overhead doors, a sound system, and built-in storage. Association amenities include Geneva Lake access to a large lakefront park, huge sandy beach, swimming piers, two diving boards, and an in-water lake slide.
5 Beds | 4 Baths | 4,520 Sq. Ft.
Sold for $1,240,000
Listed by Wendy Murphy